Sperm Count Studies – Silly Things That Make Me Smile

February 6, 2013 • Pharmacy Operations • Views: 3221

I‘m grateful for the media.  When the FDA fails to approve any new drugs for a few days, and writers like me start wondering what to write about next, there is always some study which the popular press gets hold of and runs away with. 

[adsenseyu2]

Case in point:  Low Sperm Count Attributed to Inactivity & TV Watching.

This type of headline started popping up everywhere today.  The “Health” sections of major newspapers and their corresponding websites all wanted to convey the important news that male couch potatoes may be damaging their sperm counts.  Gasp!    As one site reports: there is “a strong correlation between a lack of exercise and excess television watching and lower sperm counts.”

The study from which this information flowed was found in the online version of the British Journal on Sports Medicine.  They publish an “abstract” (summary) of the study from which, it appears, the information was gathered.  To quote the author’s conclusion:

“In this population of healthy men, higher moderate-to-vigorous activity and less TV watching were significantly associated with higher total sperm count and sperm concentration.”

But there are 2 problems with the direction most articles on this study took: 

1)  The study did not (nor claim to) say that TV watching actually CAUSED the lower sperm count and

2) The study did not suggest this low sperm count was actually a clinical problem

All the researchers have done at this point was to show a CORRELATION between men who watch more TV and lower sperm count as compared to those who workout more.  That’s it. 

Correlation, unfortunately, doesn’t tell us a whole lot.  Now, if they took the “couch potato” group and subjected them to 8 weeks of intense exercise and THEN checked their sperm counts that might given us some more information.  Maybe they could have taken the obsessively exercising group and strapped them to a boob tube for 8 weeks as well, then checked their sperm count.  That might have told us something.  But a simple correlation doesn’t really tell us diddly.  In fact, the simple correlation could be interpreted in so many ways, I personally thing MANY more creative angles could have been taken.

If I were a journalist, I might have chosen to write my article with any of the following titles instead:

Excessive Sperm Count CURED by TV watchingor

Laziness CAUSED by Low Sperm Count!” or

HIGH sperm count, NOT willpower, the reason why men exerciseor even

EXPOSED:  Gym owners appear to discriminate based up sperm count.”

Seriously.  Any of these could be valid angles in which we might happily run with the data provided.  The suggestion that the TV watcing and couch sitting actually CAUSED the low sperm count is gratuitous.  The study didn’t prove that.  The science didn’t suggest that.  But the media is happy to take the angle of their choice.  And so we have it. 

So.  Get off the couch.  Get into the gym.  Get that sperm count back up.  And maybe you’ll have less time to read some of the nonsense we find online.  

Tags:

Author: Jason Poquette

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.